top of page

Roof Repairing vs Reroofing

Which One Should You Choose?

Reroof or roof repair Calgary, which one is right for you? — a common conundrum amongst homeowners who face trouble deciphering the signs. Mull over no more! It only takes weighing down some elements to figure out whether the roofing project needs a patch up or a complete replacement.

How can you tell if it’s a simple case of repair or something that has gone beyond fixing a roofing estimate ? The secret lies in just by interpreting what the resurface is visually telling you. At first, you may not be able to make much sense out of those indications, which is why we have devised the following guide. So, read on!

Beware of The Signs

Keep your eyes wide open for the signs that a worn-out roof may exhibit, indicating that it needs attention. But the trick here is to draw a line between what is serious and what can be dealt with minor repairs. For instance, if the shingles have deteriorated to the point of no return, you have no choice but to install a new roof. For cracks, however, you can replace the affected area.

When Does Your Roof Need Replacement?

  • Structural Cracks

  • Serious water issues

  • Shingle or surface deteriorating

  • Missing granules

  • Worn-out looks.

When Does It Only Need Repairs?

  • Surficial cracks

  • Slight water leakage

  • Dark and dirty single

  • Moss outspread.

  • Sagging roof deck

Analyze the Pros and Cons

It is critical to comparatively analyze the pros and cons of both re-roofing and repairing because hasty decisions will take you nowhere. For instance, repairing the roof would call for less expenditure on materials and labor. In fact, you can even DIY some takes, making it a rather cost-effective option.

Replacement, on the other hand, is pretty time-consuming and costly. But it does come with a significant warranty option, which might save you from reroofing and frequent repairs for a considerable time. So, take your time analyzing the project, and choose wisely.

Keep Track of The Material’s Lifespan

Agreeably, nothing lasts for an eternity. It doesn’t matter whether you’ve visually come across deteriorating material, if it has lived its intended lifespan, it will fail in a matter of time. With that being said, you should keep track of the material’s lifespan and prepare yourself for the repair or replacement accordingly.

The following are some common roof material and their estimated lifespans…

  • Tiles — You’ll be stunned to find out that tiles can last for a century. But that doesn’t mean that they won’t crack or discolor. You may therefore have to repair them once in a blue moon.

  • Cedar — It doesn’t last more than two decades. That’s because cedar falls prey to changing climate, which gives birth to persistent moss.

  • Metal — Metal may last for a maximum of 80 years, even more, depending on the quality and composition. In any way, it is one of the sturdiest materials in roof construction.

  • Asphalt — Even mediocre quality asphalt can last for two entire decades. On the other hand, high-quality versions can survive a half-century.

  • Wood — It is trickiest to estimate wood’s lifespan because its survival highly depends on several external factors, including climate and atmospheric conditions. On average, it can last up to 30 years.

Repairs Are the Key to Longevity

Don’t be reluctant to repair the rooftop just because you have to replace it one day. Repairs can help lengthen the roof’s life, which will ultimately save you a good deal of investment. It may sound like a lot of work, but it will certainly save you from future trouble.

Time for a Thorough Inspection

If you still can’t decide, start by inspecting the roof from everywhere. We suggest getting a torch and make your way to the attic. Use the light to see if there are any holes or cracks and scan the area for damage and leaks. After careful assessment, you would know whether it is the case of repair or it is time to renovate the entire roof.

The inspection isn’t over yet! Now, continue the process with the outside surface and look for signs we have mentioned above in this article. You may find damaged tiles and shingles at the first glance, which will tell you all about the extent of the problem — not to forget, look for disfigured pipes, impaired chimneys, or other compromised parts for a better assessment of the damage.

Things like mold, rust, and moisture will make it easier for you to guess what’s wrong with the roof. Lastly, you must check the gutters as well and make sure that they are not blocked with granules, debris, or amassed organic matter.

What About the Layered Shingles?

Areas of heavy rains and winds usually have houses with multiple layers of shingles for maximum protection from the extreme weather. Often, the outermost layer deteriorates faster than the inner layers, but it isn’t easily identifiable for homeowners. Therefore, if you reside in an area of crazy climate, double-check each layer of shingles for better assessment.

Most of the time, you may only have to replace the outer layer, rather than replacing the whole surface. So, a close examination may help you save money as well as time.

DIYing Roof Repairs and Replacement

There isn’t anything that you can’t do. But it all comes down to your willingness and skills. For instance, if you aren’t frightened of heights and have enough time, you can easily pull off small repairs. Re-roofing, on the opposite, requires a special set of skills and tools that not every homeowner possesses.

That is where professional roof repairing, and reroofing service contractors come in. They are equipped with essential equipment, skills, and years of experience to successfully pull off all types of tasks, no matter how intricate.


Repair, when there’s still some breaths left in your roof, whereas replace the structure if it has lived its days. It is a simple formula for every homeowner who’s concerned about the roof’s health. But before you finalize your decision, make sure that you’ve run a thorough inspection to find out the overall status to avoid unnecessary investments.


bottom of page